Technical Insight
Personal Injury Trusts: Support for you and your clients with life changing injuries
The second of a two-part series, we cover Personal Injury Trusts and dispel some of the myths to help your conversations with trustees.
id
Individuals who suffer an injury following an accident or negligence, can often be awarded compensation and they may be advised to create a personal injury trust to hold these funds. In 2023 motor insurers paid out £2.4 billion in personal injury claims and the NHS paid a total of £1.992 billion in clinical negligence claims in 2022/2023.
Trustees may approach you to help them navigate some of the complexities of their role. As an adviser, you can also help them understand the investment and tax planning options available to them, with the injured person’s needs at the core of your advice.
In this second of a two-part series, we give you guidance on personal injury trusts and help dispel some of the myths. In the first part we discussed Deputies and Guardians.
We also have a guide on Personal injury payments where you can find out more about how we can support you and your clients.
id
Key points
- Personal injury trusts are created to hold and manage compensation for the injured person. This amount is disregarded in the assessment of means tested benefits.
- Trustees have a duty to obtain advice – there could be investment restrictions included in the trust.
- Reviewing the trust deed early in the advice process will help you, as an adviser, establish which investments may be suitable.
- The trust could qualify as a vulnerable person and disabled beneficiary trust and benefit from specialist tax treatment.
id
Personal Injury Trusts
Individuals who have been awarded compensation because of a personal injury can often be advised to set up a personal injury trust. This can be used towards the payment of care, equipment, modifications to the home or ongoing treatment of the individual.
The trust ring-fences the compensation from the individual’s personal assets and gives the trust the status of a personal injury trust. If personal funds, that do not relate to the compensation, are added to the trust, it will lose its status.
This type of trust can be set up as a discretionary, absolute or interest in possession trust. These trusts are drafted on a bespoke basis by the individual’s solicitor. Each type has its advantages and drawbacks, and these will be specific to the individual’s circumstances and needs which would have been discussed when the trust deed was drafted. The discretionary trust is likely to provide the most flexibility.
The person who has been awarded the compensation will be the settlor and a beneficiary of the trust. When the trust is created, the compensation is transferred to the trustees to hold and manage it for the benefit of that individual.
Protecting means tested benefits
One of the main benefits with this type of trust is the compensation payment isn’t regarded as a personal asset, it is disregarded when assessing the individuals’ eligibility to means tested benefits. The trust must be created within 52 weeks from the date the compensation is awarded for it not to be included in the assessment.
Depending on the individual’s circumstances, they may not qualify for means tested benefits today however, they could qualify in the future. Creating a personal injury trust for the compensation payment removes it from any future assessment.
This is something you may want to consider when carrying out your annual review meeting with the trustees.
Myth 1
A personal injury trust is only suitable where the individual does not have capacity to look after their own financial affairs.
id
This type of trust may also be suitable for individuals who have capacity.Myth 2
A personal injury trust cannot be created where a Deputy or Guardian has been appointed.
id
Deputies and Guardians can create this trust, provided they have authority to do this. If the Deputy or Guardianship Order doesn’t include the authority to create one, they can ask the Court to authorise it.Myth 3
Trustees can make personal investments for the individual.
id
Trustees will apply for and own any investment; they legally own the investment for the benefit of the individual.
Trustees can invest in mutual funds, National Savings products, and onshore and offshore investment bonds. Individual Savings Accounts would not be a suitable investment because they can’t be owned by trustees.
Trustees have a duty to obtain advice. The fact-find will help you draw out the income and capital needs of the beneficiary. The trust provisions can restrict the type of investments that trustees can invest in. Reviewing the trust deed early in the advice process will help you determine if there are any restrictions.
Myth 4
Income and capital paid from the trust is not assessed for means tested benefits.
id
Income and capital paid to the individual loses its protection and will be included in the assessment. This can result in the means tested benefits being reduced or lost completely.
If the individual needs specific items, the trustees may want to consider buying them for the individual to use. The individual’s entitlement to means tested benefits will not be affected if the trustees own them.
Myth 5
Personal injury trusts can't have any special tax treatment.
id
These trusts can benefit from specialist tax treatment if it qualifies as a vulnerable person and disabled beneficiary trust. Provided the trust meets the qualifying criteria, the trustees can make an election, to HM Revenue and Customs, for it to be treated as a vulnerable person and disabled beneficiary trust.
Certain conditions must be met each year for the trust to benefit from specialist tax treatment. These rules are complicated and restrict who can benefit. The trustees may want to consider these complexities and restrictions before making any election and consider obtaining specialist tax advice. Using a personal injury trust without any election may provide greater flexibility.
Case study
John is 51 and recently suffered life-changing injuries following a car accident. He has a degree of cognitive impairment which means he is unlikely to work again and has very little mobility. As a result, a significant settlement has been made into a personal injury trust, to provide for his needs. The trustees are his wife, Claire and your existing client, Alan.
John's needs
John is expected to have a shorter lifespan than before his accident, with his care needs increasing as he gets older. However, currently, Claire manages his care herself and she is conscious that she may not always be able to provide the care to John that he needs.
Some funds will be needed immediately and in the next 5 years to make adaptations to their home. And you also recommend suitable investments to fund:
- day to day living expenses
- an emergency fund and
- respite so that Claire can have a break
You suggest to the trustees that they consider investing part of the settlement into an offshore bond, with a view to long term potential growth.
This would shelter the assets from capital gains tax and potentially fund future travel for treatment. It could also be used to help provide funds in future if John's care needs increase and they need to engage a care provider. This could be done through using the tax-deferred withdrawal to pay the provider. Alternatively, the proceeds could be used to purchase an immediate care needs annuity if that is a more appropriate choice. You mention that John will need to meet the criteria for an immediate needs annuity at that time, which for most providers will include the requirement to be over 60.
The above case study is for illustrative purposes only and should not be used as a guide for advice or how to meet the financial needs of any individual client.
Finally
The role of a trustee can sometimes feel overwhelming. They must navigate the complexities of managing a trust as well as ensuring that the compensation payment can support the immediate and long term needs of the individual.
As an adviser, your support in recommending tailored investment options and financial planning solutions will help the trustees to achieve a sustainable outcome for the beneficiary.